Based on the reviews for the book you mentioned, I would start with the Young America's Foundation's list of Top Ten Conservative Colleges and their five honorable mention institutions which can be found here.
I would also recommend purchasing ISI's All-American Colleges for more options.
Thank you. I've seen the YAF list before and I own the ISI college books. However, I think Bunting's ideas are still outside the scope of what these schools offer. His program recommendatios are very unique (students begin at age 16, mastery of 2 foreign languages including a non-Western one, mandatory study abroad, emphasis on history, outdoor survival education, service and character valued over tests and grades, etc.) It's like a melding of military boot camp, Great Books education, and Officer Training School. I'm waiting to see this school come into being before my children reach college age!